On TIME Covers and the Prophet George Orwell

Ever get the feeling that you are living inside a George Orwell novel? Ever get the feeling that you’re being lied to, cleverly deceived, patronized or just plain distracted? Our print, radio and TV media universes are getting smaller and smaller while the internet swells ever larger with a more diverse range of opinions, news stories, pictures, conversations… So it is that the media changes the message and acts as gatekeepers in print, but their stranglehold on our opinions and world views is slippery, at best, on the web. For a picture says a thousand words and unless something drastic (like SOPA?) happens little folks like us will be able to take screenshots like this, which will live on long after the media outlets realize their mistake and rewrite history:

Time Magazine Covers - They Treat Americans Like Idiots

Time Magazine Covers - They Treat Americans Like Idiots - Click to View Larger

Want to know where legislation like SOPA, the Patriot Act and increasingly broad interpretation of federal and state imminent domain by the Supreme Court is taking the United States? Look no further than the UK…

You may not agree with the political views, lifestyles, and hairstyles of the 99% protesters involved in the Occupy movements around the globe. Or maybe you’re out there protesting yourself. But I can tell you one thing: Criticizing and pigeonholing them as lazy, dirty hippies is exactly what the Powers That Be want you to do. The day when then Tea Party and the Occupy movement realize how much they have in common (not that their differences aren’t profound in many ways) and get together to reinstate the INDIVIDUAL CITIZEN as the unit from which the government derives its power – not corporations; not churches; not political groups, SuperPACs, lobby groups, Centers for This or That – is the day the Orwellian nightmare comes crashing down.

But that won’t happen. I’m sorry, but I just don’t have that kind of faith in us. Instead, we’re all going to continue pointing fingers and sitting on our high horses because it’s easier than turning on the light, pulling back the shades, opening our eyes and seeing that WE sanction this distopian world in which we live. What will happen is an all-too-familiar and violent cycle will repeat itself.

When I was in college taking journalism classes I remember two Chinese students who claimed that China “liberated” Tibet from the evil Dictator, the Dalai Lama. They claimed also that the soldiers in Tiananmen Square were just protecting themselves from the violent, rioting students and that the rest of the world just didn’t like China, which is why they (as in we) made it seem like the government was being cruel. One could almost believe them for their insistence and the fact that they were geographically closer to those important points in history. That is, until I heard one of them say to the class that the reason she, and most other journalism students in China, wanted to be a journalist is so they could get rich by digging up dirt on powerful people and accepting bribe money to not print the story. Yes, she really and sincerely said that.

Looking at our TIME cover compared with the rest of the world reminds me of that experience. It reminds me how astonished I was at how brainwashed these students were, at how much control their communist government had over their media consumption and world-view through the process of propaganda, rewriting history and censorship. And it reminds me that power tends to centralize until it becomes corrupt and abusive, at which point a revolt happens, power decentralizes, anarchy and chaos rule the day for awhile, order is regained, society prospers, and power begins to centralize all over again. We are STUCK in this cycle. Remember this cycle, or something similar to it. Think about where we are in that cycle and you may have a good idea about what comes next.

5 Responses to “On TIME Covers and the Prophet George Orwell”

  1. My favorite (for now, anyway)quote is the one that says ‘Why is it easier to believe 150 million Americans are lazy, rather than 400 Americans are greedy?’. Obviously, there is more than just money involved, even though money is the catalyst for the great majority of the issues at hand. Security/stability (insert your worry here) is the main theme these people and really, all of us are concerned with. We can either let things continue the way they have, which is what the established/rich want; or we can work towards a different possibilty, even if it is unstable in the short run.
    The news outlets, are, of course a business. These businesses will put our what will ensure more money in their coffers, even if it means half-truths and fabrications. The people unwilling to give up the power they now hold take advantage of this. Certain groups, painting themselves as patriots, claim the Constitution was intended to establish a European Christian country. This despite the fact George Washington, in 1790, on a tour of the country, wrote to a synagogue in Newport, R.I. assuring them that religious liberty was for ALL, not just a select class of people, that bigotry has no room in this country. This has been ignored. Rather, with a Bible in one hand, and a flag in the other, these same people have gotten us involved in wars, also called low-level conflicts, police actions, on war on terrorism, to rattle off a few terms. We have died protecting the portfolios of these people, believing we are doing so for our country. The media is to blame, because it has misinformed us at or not informed us about what is really going on.
    SOPA would be a continuation of this, since any opposing view would be blocked for making readers, well, think for themselves. What we do, or read in the four walls of our homes is not subject to review by some outside agency, group, or government. This is oppression, Orwellian style. The thought police will come crashing through the door if we try to access a site that does not concur with whatever the current political thought is.
    Should we continue with the way political ‘business’ has been run this past quarter to half century, we on a sure path to ‘civil’ war. Unfortunately, this path is beginning more like a greased slide.

  2. Not the first time! And Time alone does not do it. Here is a collection of such covers from the past:
    http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2011/12/02/american-vs-international-news-time-and-newsweek/

  3. P.S. Just wanted to point out the opposite case: When all these ‘independent’ magazines coincidently some out with the SAME covers. Take for example when they wanted to scare you with SARS:
    Time, Newsweek, US News and World Report covers:
    http://www.ead.ae/TacSoft/images/news/WHO.jpg
    Economist cover:
    http://img.slate.com/media/1/123125/122945/2076268/2078037/2081147/030425_econ.jpg

  4. I find it amazing the garbage the media puts out and misinformation. I am young and have had the views of many of you since a teenager, citizens rights and limited government. I look at the current situation as more of a process the Nazis, or Russians implemented just slower. Slower being more like a frog in a pot heating up to boil, once its boiling its to late. I’ve ride my house of corporate media long ago and on occasion will watch it at a friends house. It’s terrifying what people believe based on what they are told. We need unbiased internet resources to know what is really going on with out that we are going to live in a society much worse then the third reich could’ve dreamed about.

  5. Very good commentary! Power corrupts; absolute power corrupts absolutely

Leave a Reply

You can use these XHTML tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>